Crime in U.S. cities isn’t a single disease—it shows up in different “stages” and “types,” just like cancer. The good news: the nation’s crime rate is falling overall. The challenge: a handful of large cities still suffer the worst rates. Here’s a clear diagnosis and a proven treatment plan.
The Quick Picture
-
Nationally, crime is cooling. FBI and independent research show violent crime and homicides declining nationwide in 2023–2024.
-
But some big cities remain hot spots. Using the latest FBI city data (2024), the five with the highest total crime rates are: Memphis, Portland, Detroit, Seattle, and Baltimore.
Where It’s Worst Right Now (Among 30 Largest U.S. Cities, FBI 2024)
| Rank | City | Total crime per 100k | Violent per 100k | Property per 100k |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Memphis, TN | 9,400.3 | 2,501.3 | 6,899.0 |
| 2 | Portland, OR | 6,246.4 | 720.1 | 5,526.2 |
| 3 | Detroit, MI | 6,086.6 | 1,781.3 | 4,305.3 |
| 4 | Seattle, WA | 5,782.7 | 775.1 | 5,007.6 |
| 5 | Baltimore, MD | 5,763.2 | 1,606.2 | 4,157.0 |
Crime Behaves Like Cancer
-
Types (like cancer subtypes):
-
Property crime = slow-spreading disease that erodes quality of life.
-
Violent crime = aggressive tumors—fewer but more damaging.
-
Gun homicide clusters = metastasis—spread through social ties.
-
-
Stages:
-
Stage I – Early disorder (thefts, burglary clusters).
-
Stage II – Recurrent flare-ups (same places/people).
-
Stage III – Chronic violence (group conflicts, retaliation).
-
Stage IV – Systemic co-morbidities (poverty, trauma, addiction, weak trust).
-
Proven Treatments (Evidence-Based Solutions)
-
Hot-spots policing – targeted, problem-solving focus on the few blocks where crime is concentrated.
-
Focused deterrence / Group Violence Intervention – precision “surgery” targeting the small groups driving violence, with both support and accountability.
-
Violence interruption – community mediators breaking retaliation cycles.
-
Environmental fixes – removing lead exposure, cleaning vacant lots, lighting, and revitalization.
-
Swift, certain, fair accountability – proportional sanctions plus strong reentry, mental health, and youth programs.
A City “Treatment Plan” for Candidates
-
Triage (First 90 Days): Public crime charts, one-map coordination.
-
Protocols (Months 3–12): Hot-spot programs, focused deterrence, violence interrupters, lead removal.
-
Supportive Care (Ongoing): Youth jobs, addiction treatment, reentry navigators.
-
Measure Outcomes (Every 90 Days): Transparent dashboards, audit results, scale what works.
Why the Cancer Analogy Matters
-
Right dose, right place: Don’t rely on blunt crackdowns—use precision interventions.
-
Whole-patient care: Fix environmental and social co-morbidities, not just symptoms.
-
Long game + short wins: Cut shootings this year and prevent the next generation from relapsing into violence.
America can keep overall crime falling and cure the worst city hot spots by treating crime like cancer: diagnose precisely, intervene precisely, and support the whole community. The tools exist. The choice is whether we use them.
